Government Struggles to Protect Children from Substance Abuse

April 15, 2024

kids playing on carousel playground Pressmaster Shutterstock

image credit: Pressmaster/Shutterstock

United States policymakers, law enforcement authorities, and the healthcare community are grappling with how to protect children exposed to drugs and alcohol by addicted parents. Earlier this year in New York, a 14-month-old boy named Joseph Adonis tragically lost his life due to poisoning from heroin, cocaine, and fentanyl.

Such heart-wrenching stories are not isolated incidents but rather indicators of a larger, ongoing crisis that has been exacerbated by the opioid epidemic.

Tragic Outcomes Nationwide

Baby infant happy sleeping toddler javi indy — image credit: javi_indy/Shutterstock

Across the nation, similar stories of neglect and tragedy unfold. In Arizona, a medically fragile toddler passed away after being left alone in a crib by substance-abusing parents. Missouri witnessed the death of a four-year-old from malnutrition and abuse at the hands of a drug-dependent caregiver. These cases highlight a systemic failure to protect the most vulnerable among us.

The Opioid Epidemic’s Toll on Children

Newborn baby pregnancy mom delivery hosptial KieferPix Shutterstock — image credit: KieferPix/Shutterstock

For over a decade, the opioid epidemic has ravaged communities, with pediatric poisonings, emergency interventions with Narcan for infants, and child fatalities on the rise. This trend signifies a dire need for action to protect children caught in the crossfire of addiction.

Shifting Approaches to Addiction

Psychotherapy psych listening mediation prostock studio shutterstock — image credit: prostock-studio/shutterstock

In response to the devastating impact of the crack-cocaine epidemic of the 1980s and 1990s, there has been a national shift toward less punitive, more rehabilitative strategies for dealing with addiction. Public opinion strongly supports this approach, particularly the call for enhanced child protective measures for the children of those battling substance abuse.

The Public’s Call to Action

Mother child refugee homeless shelter Pressmaster Shutterstock — image credit: Pressmaster/Shutterstock

A significant majority of the public advocates for the child protection system to be more responsive to the needs of children whose parents misuse drugs or alcohol. This outcry for change underscores the widespread recognition of the issue and the demand for systemic reform.

Federal Guidelines and State Responses

Politics US Capitol Building Washington Sergii Figurnyi Shutterstock — image credit: Sergii-Figurnyi/Shutterstock

Federal law mandates that states implement a “plan of safe care” for substance-exposed infants and their families. However, the execution of these plans varies significantly across states, with some merely documenting available services rather than requiring mandatory treatment. This lack of enforcement leads to many parents not receiving the necessary treatment for substance abuse.

Legislative Challenges

Downtown Denver, Colorado Kevin Ruck Shutterstock — image credit: Kevin Ruck/Shutterstock

Proposals in several states, including New York and Colorado, aim to restrict the ability of doctors to conduct toxicology tests on newborns without parental consent. This potential legislation, along with hospital policies like those at Mass General, could severely limit the ability to identify and support at-risk infants and their families.

The Cost of Inaction

Hungry children being fed by charity poor starving Zurijeta shutterstock — image credit: Zurijeta/shutterstock

Untreated parental substance abuse exposes children to an array of risks, including death, poisoning, abuse, neglect, and developmental issues. The developmental timelines of these young children do not align with the often-delayed treatment-seeking behavior of their parents, creating a gap in the care and protection they desperately need.

Centering Children in Policy

Boy child kid playing outside marbles game Stephanie F Clarke Shutterstock — image credit: Stephanie F Clarke/Shutterstock

Addressing this issue requires placing the safety and developmental needs of children as a priority in policy discussions. With parental addiction identified as a foreseeable risk, state authorities are tasked with implementing measures to mitigate these risks and support the well-being of affected children.

A Compassionate, Firm Approach to Parental Addiction

young woman tired worried stressed grief guilt sad depressed troubled sb arts media shutterstock — image credit: sb-arts-media/shutterstock

Offering parents experiencing addiction a mix of support and mandatory treatment through child protective services can serve as a powerful motivator for seeking help. This approach not only aids parents but also acts as a critical safeguard for their children.

Approaches to Protecting Children

POC Baby Toddler Son Mother Walk Stay At Home Prostock studio Shutterstock — image credit: Prostock studio/Shutterstock

“Plans of Safe Care” and Child Protective Services (CPS) interventions are two approaches within the child welfare system aimed at ensuring the safety and well-being of children, particularly those exposed to substances. While both aim to protect vulnerable children, they differ in their approach, execution, and the level of state involvement.

Plans of Safe Care

Baby Sleeping Pram Winter Olesia Bilkei Shutterstock — image credit: Olesia Bilkei/Shutterstock

Plans of Safe Care are specifically designed for infants born exposed to substances and their families. The focus is on providing a safe home environment for the child and addressing the health needs of both the infant and the caregiver.

These plans are often preventative and supportive in nature, aiming to engage families in treatment and support services voluntarily. The goal is to support families in staying together, when safe to do so, by connecting them with necessary resources such as substance abuse treatment, healthcare, and parenting support.

Child Protective Services (CPS)

upset quiet mother and kid child girl daughter fight fizkes shutterstock — image credit: fizkes/shutterstock

CPS is a state agency responsible for the protection of all children from abuse and neglect. While CPS can become involved with substance-exposed infants, their scope is broader, encompassing all forms of child maltreatment. Involvement with CPS can be involuntary, initiated through reports of concern, and potentially leading to court-ordered measures if a child’s safety is at risk.

The Role of Data in Shaping Policy

Male POC computer programmer coder jobs work Pressmaster Shutterstock — image credit: Pressmaster/Shutterstock

For these policies to be truly effective, a robust system of data collection and evaluation is necessary. Without concrete evidence to guide adjustments and improvements, policies may fall short of their intended goals, leaving children and families at risk.

Evaluating “Plans of Safe Care”

young kids children together playing Monkey Business Images shutterstock — image credit: monkey-business-images/shutterstock

The efficacy of “Plans of Safe Care” as alternatives to more traditional child protective services interventions remains unclear. A lack of comprehensive data makes it challenging to assess whether these plans genuinely serve the best interests of the children they aim to protect.

Addressing the Silent Epidemic

Teacher helps student classroom draw write PeopleImages.com Yuri A Shutterstock — image credit: PeopleImages.com Yuri A/Shutterstock

As the United States progresses towards a more empathetic approach to addiction, it is crucial not to overlook the silent victims of this epidemic—the children. Their protection and developmental needs demand urgent attention and action, ensuring they are not forgotten in the shadow of their parents’ struggles.